Penny Black Grill & Tap menu

As someone who thrives on discovering flavorful gems, Penny Black Grill & Tap's menu is a culinary playground that doesn’t disappoint. It kicks off with crave-worthy Shareables—a highlight being the Bistro Tender Tips, cooked to tender perfection, and the Buffalo Chicken Dip, a creamy, spicy crowd-pleaser. If you're into something crisp, the Flash Fried Calamari nails it with its golden crunch, while Boneless or Jumbo Traditional Wings bring the heat (and the sauces).

Salad lovers aren't forgotten—imagine the Cajun Chicken Cobb Salad with its smoky protein punch or the Village Salad bursting with Mediterranean freshness. For comfort seekers, the French Onion Soup is a melty, broiled masterpiece, and the Cream of Mushroom is earthy and velvety.

Pizza lovers, rejoice. The Hand Tossed Pizza is exactly how it should be—crispy, chewy, and cheesy. But the real surprise? The Ernie’s Americano and Vegetarian Pide, which are Turkish-style flatbreads, loaded and baked to savory bliss.

Burger fans will find heaven in the BBQ Bacon Burger or the double-pattied Corner Smash Burger, while the Handhelds like the Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich and the bold Buffalo Chicken Wrap are packed with flavor and flair.

The Faves section is like a love letter to comfort food. From the Blackened Florida Grouper to the creamy Gourmet Mac & Cheese, each dish satisfies. And yes, the Fish & Chips? A must-try.

Even the little ones get the VIP treatment with a full Kids Menu, and no meal is complete without dessert—especially the Chocolate Lava Cake, which oozes with indulgence.

Bottom line: whether you're grazing or feasting, Penny Black's menu offers something tempting at every turn.